Peanut Butter & Jelly: Self-Expression Between Two Slices

By: Jeff Vogel, posted Apr 2, 2009 at 8:30 am

View Comments

peanutbutter&jelly

There are few sandwiches as prolific in America as the peanut butter & jelly. Usually served on white bread with creamy peanut butter and grape jelly, the PB&J is one of those rare creations where everyone has an opinion and naturally, that opinion is right.  And on this National Peanut Butter & Jelly Day, we thought we’d look at some of the burning issues of our time:

What’s the ratio of peanut butter to jelly?
Chunky or creamy peanut butter?
Jelly, jam or preserves? With seeds or smooth?
Apple butter? Are you serious with that?
Cut in half or in quarters? Straight across or diagonal?
Have you ever heard of food allergies?? Get away from my child.

Whether interpretive or classical, the permutations and choices are what makes PB&J a true canvas for any sandwich maker. Do you channel the sandwich of your youth or create your own stamp? Tell us about it in the comments.

Pictured: Organic peanut butter (with sugar) and all natural black cherry preserves on multigrain toast. Cut on a diagonal. 60/40 peanut butter to jelly.

Tweet


Tags: , ,

If you enjoyed this post, please leave a comment or subscribe to the feed to get future articles delivered to your feed reader.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jameson-Detweiler/10501349 Jameson Detweiler

    I <3 PBJ. I've been eating it almost every day for the past few weeks. Not sure why. Just give me some crunchy organic peanut butter (Trader Joe's ain't bad), virtually any jelly, jam, preserves, a banana, basically anything sweet, and some whole wheat bread, and I'm happy regardless of the ratios.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jameson-Detweiler/10501349 Jameson Detweiler

    I <3 PBJ. I've been eating it almost every day for the past few weeks. Not sure why. Just give me some crunchy organic peanut butter (Trader Joe's ain't bad), virtually any jelly, jam, preserves, a banana, basically anything sweet, and some whole wheat bread, and I'm happy regardless of the ratios.

  • scrambles

    I grew up eating Skippy SuperChunk & grape jelly on toasted rye (dad's preferred sandwich). On my own, I switched to strawberry or raspberry preserves. In the most recent years, my version is TJ's Valencia peanut butter (chunky), some sort of berry preserves, and whatever bread (usually wheat, multigrain, or rye) is on hand. Ratio was pretty equal, careful never to overload the sandwich lest the filling glop out when biting the hot, crispy toast.

    Fun variations: peanut butter/banana/honey (sometimes granola added for extra crunch). A favorite cafe used to serve an open face pbj with creamy peanut butter topped with roasted peanuts on one side, and strawberry jam topped with sliced fresh strawberries on the other. So good!

    Mmm…need milk.

  • scrambles

    I grew up eating Skippy SuperChunk & grape jelly on toasted rye (dad's preferred sandwich). On my own, I switched to strawberry or raspberry preserves. In the most recent years, my version is TJ's Valencia peanut butter (chunky), some sort of berry preserves, and whatever bread (usually wheat, multigrain, or rye) is on hand. Ratio was pretty equal, careful never to overload the sandwich lest the filling glop out when biting the hot, crispy toast.

    Fun variations: peanut butter/banana/honey (sometimes granola added for extra crunch). A favorite cafe used to serve an open face pbj with creamy peanut butter topped with roasted peanuts on one side, and strawberry jam topped with sliced fresh strawberries on the other. So good!

    Mmm…need milk.

  • Ben Greenberg

    I eat peanut butter sandwiches at least 3 days a week; often 5 days a week. Here are some thoughts on peanut butter:

    Plain peanut butter sandwiches are excellent toasted in the toaster oven if you use a heartier, whole grain bread.

    Most grocery store peanut butter claims “0g trans fat” but are still made with Hydrogenated Vegetable Oil, which is a source of trans fat. They can get away with it because the FDA allows serving sizes that contain less than 0.5g trans fat to list as zero. So if you eat peanut butter at all regularly, it is well worth it to get a variety that uses palm oil or some other natural oil. Peanut butters with no added oil are ok, but the oil separates making them hard to use and are less creamy.

    Low fat peanut butter is a scam and it almost certainly less healthy than real peanut butter. Look at the nutrition information; you are saving maybe 2g of fat with this variety per serving by substituting highly processed fillers for the healthy oils that occur in peanuts (the ones that help prevent heart disease). The calorie and fat content difference is negligible, and of course it doesn't taste as good. Why do people eat this crap?

    Don't even get me started on most jellies that are 90% high fructose corn syrup.

    Sometimes I like to change things up with Sunflower Seed Butter from Trader Joe's. It's naturally sweet and has a great flavor.

    Another excellent twist is combing tahini (sesame paste) with peanut butters. It's a little messier, but it's delicious.

    All that aside, PB and PB&J are great, cheap, simple sandwiches.

  • Ben Greenberg

    I eat peanut butter sandwiches at least 3 days a week; often 5 days a week. Here are some thoughts on peanut butter:

    Plain peanut butter sandwiches are excellent toasted in the toaster oven if you use a heartier, whole grain bread.

    Most grocery store peanut butter claims “0g trans fat” but are still made with Hydrogenated Vegetable Oil, which is a source of trans fat. They can get away with it because the FDA allows serving sizes that contain less than 0.5g trans fat to list as zero. So if you eat peanut butter at all regularly, it is well worth it to get a variety that uses palm oil or some other natural oil. Peanut butters with no added oil are ok, but the oil separates making them hard to use and are less creamy.

    Low fat peanut butter is a scam and it almost certainly less healthy than real peanut butter. Look at the nutrition information; you are saving maybe 2g of fat with this variety per serving by substituting highly processed fillers for the healthy oils that occur in peanuts (the ones that help prevent heart disease). The calorie and fat content difference is negligible, and of course it doesn't taste as good. Why do people eat this crap?

    Don't even get me started on most jellies that are 90% high fructose corn syrup.

    Sometimes I like to change things up with Sunflower Seed Butter from Trader Joe's. It's naturally sweet and has a great flavor.

    Another excellent twist is combing tahini (sesame paste) with peanut butters. It's a little messier, but it's delicious.

    All that aside, PB and PB&J are great, cheap, simple sandwiches.

blog comments powered by Disqus