No Matter How You Cut It…

By: Ben Kessler, posted Nov 30, 2009 at 12:00 pm

View Comments

No Matter How You Cut It

When building that perfect sandwich, the one that fills you up and satisfies you like no other, the last thing one might think twice about is cutting it in half. Most people are programmed based on how their sandwiches were cut for them at a young age. But we’ve pondered this for a long time; which makes for a more perfect sandwich – the cross cut or diagonal cut?

Fortunately, Alice Winkler of NPR’s All Things Considered decided to find a definitive answer to this age old question. Kevin Harris, an architect in Baton Rouge explains that cutting on the diagonal greatly exposes the inside of the sandwich saying, “by exposing the interior, it engages more of your senses before you take the first bite.” It’s more about the illusion of a larger sandwich for Kemp Minifie, former executive food editor of Gourmet Magazine. She is confident that as human beings we want more excitement from life, to think out of the box, and too summons architecture, “right angles can be boring, think of rooms – we like curved windows, bay windows.”

The thinking gets even deeper when Winkler discusses the concept with Paul Calter emeritus professor of mathematics at Vermont Technical College. Listen to the audio excerpt and read the article to learn how Plato most likely ate his sandwiches.

Let us know in the comments how you prefer to cut your sandwich. Further more, we would like to propose the following question: When eating a sandwich on sliced bread, do you bite in from the middle or the corner?

Rectangle Vs. Triangle: The Great Sandwich Debate [NPR]

Tweet


Tags: , , ,

If you enjoyed this post, please leave a comment or subscribe to the feed to get future articles delivered to your feed reader.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=667838456 facebook-667838456

    NPR leaves out one crucial, crucial element of this debate — the ability of the sandwich to hold up to actual eating.

    I don't think you will find anyone to disagree that the diagonal sandwich looks a bit nicer — and if you are eating PB&J or grilled cheese, that is fine. But when you are eating a serious sandwich — for example the Thanksgiving leftover sandwich, for example, which should have at least 4 or 5 ingredients, those sharp triangle corners simply do not adequately hold in the sandwich filling. And what is a sandwich if not filling held between two pieces of bread? It is certainly not two corners of bread with filling on your plate.

    So, at the end of the day, while the triangle might be prettier, the square cut is for more versatile and useful, and thus gets my vote.

  • http://www.spiltwine.amberhorizon.com/ yoko

    If I were making a sandwich with square slices of bread, I would cut it diagonally. If I were using more oval slices (rye or pumpernickel) or round (kaiser roll), I would cross-cut it.

  • http://www.spiltwine.amberhorizon.com/ yoko

    Hmm… I suppose it's technically not possible to diagonal-cut a round roll.

  • http://alleblog.com/ Allebach Communications

    Very entertaining article. Cut diagonally, bite in the middle. Love that research actually went into figuring out this dilemma.

blog comments powered by Disqus